Build a Loyal, High-Performing Team Without Burning Out

One of the biggest pain points for studio owners isn’t just hiring great staff members—it’s keeping them. High turnover drains time, resources, and energy, forcing you into an endless cycle of recruiting and training. But what if there was a better way?

In a past BFS  session, we explored how to build a team that stays long-term—not just by offering competitive pay, but by creating a structure that supports their career goals, work-life balance, and financial stability.

Why a One-Size-Fits-All Model Doesn't Work

Some instructors want to teach full-time, while others are passionate but can only commit to a few classes per week. Instead of forcing everyone into the same mold, the most successful studios build flexible employment models that accommodate different levels of commitment while ensuring consistency for members.

A hybrid workforce that includes both part-time and full-time collaborators allows studios to:

• Ensure class coverage when instructors take vacations or need time off.
• Retain top talent by offering sustainable career paths for those who want to teach full-time.
• Create a balance that keeps the business running smoothly while supporting staff needs.

How Compensation Impacts Instructor Retention

If you’re only paying a flat rate per class, you may be undervaluing your best collaborators and unintentionally driving them to look elsewhere. A tiered compensation model that rewards tenure, performance, and demand helps keep great staff members invested in your studio’s success.

For example, some studios:

• Offer a base pay per class plus a bonus for additional attendance (e.g., per head after a certain number of attendees).
• Provide raises based on tenure and client feedback, ensuring that long-standing, high-performing instructors feel valued.
• Incentivize full-time instructors with benefits like health insurance, 401(k) options, PTO, and even parental leave bonuses to create real career opportunities in the fitness industry.

These structures improve retention and directly impact class quality and customer satisfaction. When instructors are motivated to grow within your studio, they bring their best energy to every class.

Keeping Staff Happy Means Keeping Members Happy

Ultimately, a well-supported team leads to a stronger business. Happy staff members mean better classes, more engaged members, and higher retention and profitability.

When staff feel valued, appreciated, and financially secure, they’re more likely to:

• Stay with your studio long-term
• Build strong relationships with members
• Deliver consistently high-quality classes

If you want to stop losing great staff members to burnout, inconsistent pay, or lack of career growth, it’s time to rethink how you support and incentivize your team.

We're discussing topics like this in the Studio Operations Optimization Program led by Physique57's Co-Founder & CEO, Jennifer Maanavi.
If you want to dive deeper into actionable strategies that help you lead, not just manage, your business, join us for the full program.

.